Agenda Date: February 14, 2001 Item No.: 2D Docket: UW-010024 Company Name: Washington Water Service Company Staff: Danny P. Kermode, Revenue Requirements Specialist Penny Hansen, Public Involvement Coordinator Recommendation: Issue a Complaint and Order Suspending the Tariff Revisions Filed by Washington Water Service Company in Docket UW-010024. Discussion: On January 9, 2001, Washington Water Service Company, (Washington Water) filed a revision to its currently effective Tariff WN U-1. In its filing, the Company proposes an increase in rates totaling $416,000 or a 11.8 percent increase in its annual revenue. The Company serves approximately 15,000 customers located in Pierce, Thurston, Kitsap, and Mason Counties. Washington Water cites increased costs of water testing and reporting, and increased operating expenses as the reasons for the filing. In addition, the company has proposed rate design changes that both promote water conservation and provide a first step towards Single Tariff Pricing for the entire company. The commission received 29 comments opposed. Customers think that the proposed increases are excessive and state that the company should look for methods of reducing overall costs. Customers also commented that it was their understanding that when Washington Water Services purchased the companies that were previously providing service to them that their rates would eventually go down due to the larger customer base over which costs could be spread. Customers also stated they are already conserving water and believe the proposed rate structure is unjust. Additionally, customers have expressed their opposition to the water treatment surcharge of $.50 per month. They believe that this expense is already covered in the base rate charge. A sample of the current and proposed rates are provided below: Monthly Rates: Current Proposed Percent Flat Rates Harbor District – Residential $20.00 $26.00 30% Monthly Rates: Current Proposed Percent Flat Rates (cont) Country Store Residential 10.00 26.00 160% Commercial 36.00 26.00 -28% Metered Rates Harbor District Current Proposed Percent Base Rate ¾ Inch Meter $16.00 $13.60 Usage included 400 Cubic ft. None Usage Charge 0-400 Cubic ft $0.00 $1.00 401-1400 Cubic ft 0.70 1.15 64% Over 1400 Cubic ft 0.80 1.30 63% Talmo System Current Proposed Percent Base Rate ¾ Inch Meter $13.50 $13.60 Usage included 400 Cubic ft. None Usage Charge 0-400 Cubic ft $0.00 $1.00 401-1400 Cubic ft 0.50 1.15 130% Over 1400 Cubic ft 0.58 1.30 124% Staff and the company are currently engaged in continuing discussions. Staff and Washington Water agree on the need for further analysis before a final recommendation can be provided. However, Staff expects that this filing will be once again brought before this Commission at its next open meeting, which is February 23, 2001. Therefore Staff recommends that the Commission issue a Complaint and Order Suspending the Tariff Revisions Filed by Washington Water Service Company in Docket UW-010024.