Agenda Date: March 29, 2000 Item Numbers: Dockets: TG-000423, TG-000424, and TG-000425 Company Names: Waste Management of Washington, Inc. f/k/a Washington Waste Hauling and Recycling, Inc. d/b/a Waste Management - Sno-King (G237) d/b/a Waste Management - Northwest (G-237) d/b/a Waste Management - Rainier (G-237) Staff: Layne Demas, Transportation Staff Recommendation: Issue a complaint and order suspending the above-named companies and dockets. Grant the proposed rates on a temporary basis effective April 1, 2000, on less than statutory notice. Discussion: On March 21, 2000, the above companies, all under common ownership and control, filed proposed tariff revisions naming revised residential and multi-family deferred recycling credits to become effective April 1, 2000. Sno-King serves Northeast King County North of Interstate 90 up to the Snohomish County line. Northwest serves in Eastern Snohomish County and a small portion of Northern King County. Rainier serves in King County south of Interstate 90 and East of State Route 167. Existing credits expire March 31, 2000. These filings are a part of the normal annual review of the value of the commodities collected in the carriers’ deferred recycle programs and the resulting impacts on the net charges customers pay for the service. The credit (the commodities have value) is the sum of the estimated future value of commodities (based on the current three month average) plus an adjustment for any differences between what was estimated the prior year and subsequent actual results. For these filings, the carrier has elected to base it’s future estimate of commodity value using actual results obtained over the last twelve months, not the most recent three month activity. The resulting credits to customers, while larger than current credits, are less than would be the case of using the more recent three month data. The three month average approach is the method used by staff and is all other carriers with deferral programs. It is the approach recommended by Staff and has been approved by the Commission in various orders issued to other carriers in prior deferred recycle dockets. The proposed departure from 3 months to 12 months is due to a current suspended filing by another carrier, seeking a 12 month measurement period. The outcome of the currently suspended filing will determine the outcome of these filings. A representative sample of residential curbside recycle present, proposed (12 month), and Staff methodology (3 months) credits follows: Staff Proposed Methodology Present (12 month) (3 month) Sno-King Base Amount $1.46 $1.99 $2.67 Def’d Adjustment -0.59 0.57 0.61 Net Credit 0.87 2.56 3.28 Northwest Base Amount $1.01 $1.47 $1.96 Def’d Adjustment -0.92 0.49 0.51 Net Credit 0.09 1.96 2.47 Rainier Base Amount $1.27 $1.75 $2.17 Def’d Adjustment -0.71 0.38 0.40 Net Credit 0.56 2.13 2.57 It is therefore recommended that the Commission suspend the filings for the above-named companies and dockets, and grant the proposed rates on a temporary basis per LSN order effective April 1, 2000.